Centre for Reasoning events

Please see the Centre for Reasoning pages for further information on the Centre.Two young suricates

Evidence seminars. These tend to focus on the epistemology and methodology of current science, mathematics and medicine. These normally take place weekly. Please contact Jon Williamson if you would like to attend.

Workshops and Conferences

16-17 July 2020: Evidential Pluralism and the social sciences. To attend (on Zoom) please contact Yafeng Shan

13-15 July 2020: British Society for the Philosophy of Science. CANCELLED. contact  Graeme Forbes.

24-26 June 2020: Time: from theory to practice. CANCELLED contact Graeme Forbes.

19 May 2020: Symposium on analogical reasoning. 2-6pm, room KS4. POSTPONED contact Yafeng Shan

12 May 2020: Knowledge-first epistemology applied to science. POSTPONED contact Michael Wilde.

3 July 2019: Type theory, category theory and philosophy, 10-5pm. Cornwallis East Seminar Room 1. To attend please contact David Corfield.

11 June 2019: New directions in medical methodology, University of Kent, 11.30am-5pm, W1-SR5. To attend please contact Jon Williamson.

11.30-12. Alexandra Trofimov: Clarifying the duty to inform. Video
12-12.30. Michael Wilde: Expanding the notion of evidence in evidence-based medicine. Video
lunch at the Gulbenkian
2.15-2.45. Jon Williamson: Evidential proximity, independence, and the evaluation of carcinogenicity. Video
2.45-3.15. Daniel Auker-Howlett: Domain expertise in evidence evaluation. Video
3.45-4.15. Virginia Ghiara: Collecting mechanistic evidence to design and evaluate immunisation programmes. Video
4.15-4.45. David Corfield: Health methodology and the psychosomatic approach to medicine. Video

This workshop will explore practical consequences of recent philosophical work on health. Talks will be accessible to the general public. The workshop is organised by the Health Methodology Group of the Centre for Reasoning at the University of Kent. This group works on the foundations of evidence-based medicine and values-based healthcare, as well as concepts of health and disease and problems to do with medicine and the law.

7 May 2019: Symposium on Inductive logic, University of Kent, 3-5.30pm, CESR1. To attend please contact Jon Williamson.

Juergen Landes, Munich
Soroush Rafiee Rad, Bayreuth
Jon Williamson, Kent

This symposium will provide a gentle introduction to inductive logic, including the Carnapian tradition and Bayesian approaches. We will outline some recent developments in the Carnapian tradition and explore in some depth an exciting new challenge for the Bayesian approaches: the entropy limit conjecture.

5 February 2019: Symposium on Health Methodology, University of Kent, 3-5.30pm, Room TBC. To attend please contact Jon Williamson.

Daniel Auker-Howlett: “Evaluating Evaluating evidence of mechanisms in medicine
David Corfield: “How to understand ‘placebo’ and ‘psychosomatic'”

Virginia Ghiara: “New quality assessment tools for the NHS”
Michael Wilde: “Mechanistic evidence in medical consensus conferences”

This symposium will explore present some new work of the Health Methodology Group of the Centre for Reasoning at the University of Kent. This group works on the foundations of evidence-based medicine and values-based healthcare, as well as concepts of health and disease and problems to do with medicine and the law.

20 November 2018: Symposium on Models, University of Kent, 3-5pm, SIBSR3. To attend please contact Michael Wilde.

Jason Konek, Bristol
Camillia Kong,
Veli-Pekka Parkkinen, Bergen

In order to better understand some phenomenon, a scientist will sometimes build a model of the phenomenon. For example, to better understand some biomedical phenomenon, a scientist might try to build a model of the mechanism responsible for the phenomenon. Some philosophers also build models. For example, some epistemologists have appealed to formal models in an attempt to understand the nature of rational degrees of belief. How is this model-building activity supposed to aid understanding, given that the models are often highly idealized? And is this model-building activity even legitimate in philosophy? In this symposium, a group of philosophers will try to answer these questions by discussing the role of models in science and philosophy.

19 June 2018: Practical and Foundational Aspects of Type Theory, University of Kent.

2-3 May 2018: Connecting the medical humanities with healthcare, Royal Asiatic Society, London.

18-19 December 2017: Formal epistemology conference, University of Kent.

4-5 September 2017: Evidence of Mechanisms, University of Kent

3-5 July 2017: Mechanisms in Medicine, University of Kent.

22-23 June 2017: Big data in the social sciences, University of Kent.

18-19 May 2017: Reasoning Club Conference, Turin.

15 May 2017: Inferring Policy from Experiments, Cornwallis Octagon Lecture Theatre 3, University of Kent. Conference report on the EBM+ Blog. Conference report in The Reasoner.

10.30 – 11.50 Nancy Cartwright – Two Approaches to EBHP: Intervention-centring, Context-centring. Slides. Audio.
13.15 – 14.35 Sarah Wieten – What good are pragmatic trials? Slides. Audio.
14.45 – 16.05 Mike Kelly – Inferring policy from evidence?  The case of non-communicable disease and health inequalities in the UK. Slides. Audio.

24 March 2017: Symposium on the Principal Principle, GS8, University of Kent, 2-4pm.

Jon Williamson (University of Kent): The principal principle implies the principle of indifference
Christian Wallmann (University of Kent): On the unviability of the principal principle
Richard Pettigrew (University of Bristol): The principal principle does not imply the principle of indifference

Background. Recently, Hawthorne, Landes, Wallmann and Williamson argued in a joint paper that the principal principle implies the principle of indifference. Jon Williamson will present and defend their alrgument. Richard Pettigrew argues that 1) Hawthorne et al’s argument does not apply to Levi’s principal principle and that 2) Hawthorne et al’s argument presupposes the principle of indifference and is therefore circular.  Christian Wallmann argues that the principal principle is itself unviable and that therefore Hawthorne et al’s argument does not support the principle of indifference.

20 March 2017: Symposium on objective Bayesianism, KS1, University of Kent, 3-5pm.

Fabrizio Leisen (University of Kent, Statistics)
Cristiano Villa (University of Kent, Statistics)
Jon Williamson (University of Kent, Philosophy)

Background. This interdisciplinary symposium is dedicated to objective Bayesianism—the thesis that in absence of any information there are still rational constraints on prior probability distributions. The symposium introduces objective Bayesianism and discusses its philosophical and statistical foundations. It then examines a particular prior distribution that is supposed to satisfy the tenets of objective Bayesianism. Finally, this prior is applied to a skewed t-model and an important invariance property is established within this model.

5-6 September 2016: Workshop. Buiding EBM, UCL.

20 June 2016: Workshop. New frontiers for evaluating evidence in medicine. UCL.

9-10 June 2016. Workshop. Type theory and philosophy. W1-SR6.

16 May 2016. Workshop: Explanation and evidence of mechanisms across the sciences, University of Kent.

9.00-10.00   Jürgen Landes – ‘Role of mechanisms in causal inference in pharmacology’
10.15-11.15 Gry Oftedal – ‘Intervention and explanation in research on targeted cancer treatment’
11.15-12.15 Julian Reiss – ‘Evidential reasoning about a target without extrapolation?’
13.45-14.45 Beate Krickel – ‘Against activities’
14.45-15.45 Phyllis Illari & Brendan Clarke – ‘Heuristics and inference methods’
16.00-17.00 Jaakko Kuorikoski – ‘Weighing Evidence: A Mechanism-Based Approach’

12 May 2016. Workshop: Processes, University of Kent.

9.15-11.00 John Dupre (Exeter) – ‘Process, Organisms, and Kinds.’
11.15-13.00 Johanna Seibt (Aarhus) – ‘What is (a) process?’
14.00-15.45 Thomas Crowther (Warwick) – ‘An Ontology of Processes’
16.00-17.45 James Williams (Deakin)  – ‘Dangerous illusions of autonomy: a process critique of the concept of autopoiesis’

21 January 2016.  EBM+ workshop. Amsterdam.


Reasoning-related talks

6 April 2017. Forecasting, Investment and Global Politics, 10am-1pm, GLT3.

28 February 2017. Ursula Martin (University of Oxford): The future of proof: will we need people in the age of computers? School of Computing Seminar, SW101, 4pm.

15 December 2016. Nick Chater: Joint Reasoning in Social Interaction: A Virtual Bargaining Approach, 3-4.30pm, GLT2.

23 November 2016. Neil Levy: The Rationality of Climate Change Skeptics, 3-5pm.

9 November 2016. Silvia Jonas: Realism, Evolution, and the A Priori, 12-2pm, CNW seminar room 8.

26 October 2016. David Corfield: A very gentle introduction to a new type theory, 3-5pm, RDC-G22.

3 October 2016. Room GS6:
1400—1530: Conrad and Sarah Heilmann: Two cheers for RCTs.
1530—1700: Jon Williamson: Establishing causal claims in medicine.

Some other talks relating to reasoning, inference and method can be found here.