A new study by the Durrell Institute of Conservation and Ecology (DICE) suggests that utilising Confucianist, Daoist and Buddhist belief messaging in targeted campaigns could effectively change the behaviour of end consumers in the East Asia illegal wildlife trade chain.
Behavioural-change intervention is essential for reducing the demand of illegal wildlife products. With so many conservation campaigns typically approached from the perspective of Western culture, the impact could be limited in different cultures. East Asia is a primary market for many illegal wildlife products such as rosewood, ivory and pangolin scales, and so is often targeted with conservation campaigns, with limited effect.
The research, led by Laura Thomas-Walters, who is studying for a PhD in Biodiversity Management at DICE, has identified that resonating with Chinese-influenced societies through cultural values could be most effective for tailoring the messaging in illegal wildlife trade campaigns in East Asia. While China alone has 56 recognised ethnic groups, Confucianism, Daoism and Buddhism have dominated traditional Chinese ideology.
The study highlighted eight cultural concepts to target messaging around: Harmony (the balance of yin and yang), Jian (frugality), Junzi (an exemplary person), Li (ritual propriety), Qi (the material force of the universe), Ren (inner moral force, humaneness), Shu (altruism) and Zhong (conscientiousness).
For example, in regards to the concept of harmony, messaging could be based around unsustainable product use and the imbalance between humans and nature when species such as pangolins disappear. Whilst, in regards to Ren, messaging could reinforce the concept of connection and unity with nature by relating the kindness of humanity to include wildlife.
Laura Thomas-Walters said, “Chinese culture has a long history of consumptive wildlife use and conservationists have struggled to engage Chinese-influenced societies with illegal wildlife trade campaigns. This study suggests routes that could be taken to target these societies more specifically. Yet it’s important to consider that, when designing an intervention, respect rather than judgement is essential and the involvement of a local partnership or regional expertise is recommended.”
The paper titled, Targeted values: The relevance of classical Chinese philosophy for illegal wildlife demand reduction campaigns, by Laura Thomas-Walters, Hubert Cheung, Tien Ming Lee, Anita Kar Yan Wan and Yifu Wang is published in People & Nature. (DOI: 10.1002/pan3.10127.)