New research highlights damaging social cost of ‘litigation culture’ on health and education

New research by Professor Frank Furedi of the University of Kent highlights the high social cost of today’s ‘culture of litigation’ on health and education services.

The report, by Professor Furedi and Jennie Bristow of the University’s School of Social Policy, Sociology and Social Research, is published today (10 September) by the Centre for Policy Studies.

In The Social Cost of Litigation, the authors show that far from increasing safety and accountability, the culture of litigation has resulted in significant costs to the quality of services, the experience of those who use them, and the role of professionals.

Professor Furedi said: ‘Demanding recompense for accidents is now perceived, not only as a common-sense way of gaining financial compensation, but as a way of holding public services to account.

‘But taken together, the combination of an engrained compensation culture and litigation avoidance is bleeding the health and education services dry: both financially, and in terms of their public sector ethos and professional role.’

The research shows that as of March 2011, the NHS Litigation Authority estimated its potential liabilities at £16.8 billion, of which £16.6 billion related to clinical negligence claims.

However, of the 63,800 claims for medical negligence made since 2001, only about 2,000 (3.2%) have had damages approved or set by the Court. A further 28,700 were settled out of court.

Professor Furedi said: ‘The increasing fear of litigation is also extremely damaging to the professionalism of doctors, nurses and teachers: it erodes professional autonomy, stifles innovation, leads to defensive practices in both hospitals and schools and encourages greater bureaucracy. ‘Best practice’ is now defined as having checked all the boxes in a quality assurance form rather than doing what is best of the patient or pupil.

‘If we want to put a brake on the culture of litigation and litigation avoidance in Britain, we need to look beyond ambulance-chasers and greedy lawyers to the cultural conditions that have allowed litigious sentiments to flourish as common sense. In particular, we need to challenge the expectation that professional ‘best practice’ in the public sector should be measured by the absence of complaints or litigation.’’The Social Cost of Litigation is available from the Centre for Policy Studies www.cps.org.uk

Adult Health and Social Care forum

Dear Colleagues,

At the last Adult Health and Social Care group meeting we decided that there was value in having the group and continuing to hold regular face-to-face meetings. However, in order to promote dialogue within the group outside this infrequent coming together, we decided to trail an e-forum which enthusiastic members could use to post ideas/information and promote discussions. This is the initiation of that process and we have posted a page which contains the report of our last workshop, slides and videos of the presentations and an opportunity to start a dialogue. This is an attempt to see if people engage with the forum – if they do we will maintain it and expand it’s usefulness – if they don’t we’ll take it down again in a month or two – it’s up to you!

The forum is completely private and can only be read by users with the correct authentications. The access the forum please click log in towards the right hand column of this page.

If you have any questions at all please feel free to either contact either myself or my forums administrator, Luca Macis (G.Macis@kent.ac.uk)

Kind regards,
Peter Jeffries.

E-health forum setup

Dear Colleagues,

At the last e-Health group meeting we decided that there was value in having the group and continuing to hold regular face-to-face meetings. However, in order to promote dialogue within the group outside this infrequent coming together, we decided to trail an e-forum which enthusiastic members could use to post ideas/information and promote discussions. This is the initiation of that process and we have posted an initial question about the MRC/TSB Biocatalyst call to see if people engage with the forum – if they do we will maintain it and expand it’s usefulness – if they don’t we’ll take it down again in a month or two – it’s up to you!

The forum is completely private and can only be read by users with the correct authentications. The access the forum please click log in towards the right hand column of this page.

If you have any questions at all please feel free to either contact either myself or my forums administrator, Luca Macis (G.Macis@kent.ac.uk)

Kind regards,
Peter Jeffries.